Daily

Random

Practice set

Baltic Way 2011 · Shortlist problem

Number Theory

Nonnegative integers aa and bb have the following property: d(na)≥d(nb)d(na) \ge d(nb) for each positive integer nn (where d(k)d(k) is the number of divisors of kk). Prove that aa is divisible by bb.

Change pool

When you’re ready

Review material becomes available with the next Daily.

Review

Topics

Divisibility and factorization · Arithmetic functions

Solutions

Solution

Let a=p1α1…pmαma = p_1^{\alpha_1} \dots p_m^{\alpha_m}, b=p1β1…pmβmb = p_1^{\beta_1} \dots p_m^{\beta_m} be the prime decompositions of these numbers (we assume that some αk,βk\alpha_k, \beta_k can be equal to 00). Let us check that for each kk αk≥βk\alpha_k \ge \beta_k. Indeed, if the inequality does not hold for some kk, say, α1<β1\alpha_1 < \beta_1, then for n=p2s…pmsn = p_2^s \dots p_m^s we have

1≤d(na)d(nb)=α1(s+α2)…(s+αm)β1(s+β2)…(s+βm)1 \le \frac{d(na)}{d(nb)} = \frac{\alpha_1(s + \alpha_2) \dots (s + \alpha_m)}{\beta_1(s + \beta_2) \dots (s + \beta_m)}

For big ss this fraction is close to α1β1<1\frac{\alpha_1}{\beta_1} < 1. A contradiction.