Daily

Random

Practice set

Baltic Way 1990 · Problem 19

Combinatorics

What is the largest possible number of subsets of the set {1,2,…,2n+1}\{1,2, \ldots, 2 n+1\} such that the intersection of any two subsets consists of one or several consecutive integers?

Change pool

When you’re ready

Review material becomes available with the next Daily.

Review

Topics

Colorings and configurations · Pigeonhole and extremal arguments

Solutions

Solution

Solution: Consider any subsets A1,…,AsA_{1}, \ldots, A_{s} satisfying the condition of the problem and let Ai={ai1,…,ai,ki}A_{i} = \{a_{i1}, \ldots, a_{i,k_{i}}\} where ai1<⋯<ai,kia_{i1} < \cdots < a_{i,k_{i}}. Replacing each AiA_{i} by Ai′={ai1,ai1+1,…,ai,ki−1,ai,ki}A_{i}' = \{a_{i1}, a_{i1}+1, \ldots, a_{i,k_{i}}-1, a_{i,k_{i}}\} (i.e., adding to it all "missing" numbers) yields a collection of different subsets A1′,…,As′A_{1}', \ldots, A_{s}' which also satisfies the required condition.

Now, let bib_{i} and cic_{i} be the smallest and largest elements of the subset Ai′A_{i}', respectively. Then min⁡1≤i≤sci≥max⁡1≤i≤sbi\min_{1 \leq i \leq s} c_{i} \geq \max_{1 \leq i \leq s} b_{i}, as otherwise some subsets Ak′A_{k}' and Al′A_{l}' would not intersect. Hence there exists an element a∈⋂1<i<sAi′a \in \bigcap_{1 < i < s} A_{i}'.

As the number of subsets of the set {1,2,…,2n+1}\{1,2, \ldots, 2n+1\} containing aa and consisting of kk consecutive integers does not exceed min⁡(k,2n+2−k)\min(k, 2n+2-k), we have s≤(n+1)+2⋅(1+2+⋯+n)=(n+1)2s \leq (n+1) + 2 \cdot (1+2+\cdots+n) = (n+1)^{2}. This maximum will be reached if we take a=n+1a = n+1.